ACX Ready / Peak level too high

ACX says your peak level is too high

"Each file must have peak values no higher than -3dB to avoid distortion."

ACX, ACX audio submission requirements

The peak is the single loudest sample in the file. One shouted word, a laugh or a plosive can set it. If any point in the chapter goes above -3 dB, the whole file fails.

Why it happens

Peaks usually go over after the file was turned up to meet the RMS range. Normalising to a peak of 0 dB or -1 dB also does it, since some editors default to that. Plosives on "p" and "b" sounds make sharp spikes that stand well above normal speech.

MP3 encoding can also push peaks up slightly. A WAV that peaks at exactly -3.0 dB can measure a little higher once it's an MP3, so leave a margin.

How to fix it in Audacity

  1. Select the whole track.
  2. Open Effect > Volume and Compression > Limiter. Use a soft or hard limit with the level at -3.5 dB, which gives a margin for MP3 encoding.
  3. Export the MP3, open it back in Audacity and run Analyze > ACX Check on the exported file.
  4. If RMS dropped below -23 dB after limiting, raise it with Loudness Normalization, then limit again.

Don't fix peaks with Normalize alone. It turns the whole file down until the loudest point fits, which often drops RMS below -23 dB.

How to fix it in Reaper

  1. Add a limiter to the track or master, such as ReaLimit or the JS Master Limiter. Set the ceiling to -3.5 dB.
  2. Or, in File > Render, open Normalize/Limit and turn on the brickwall limit at -3.5 dB.
  3. Render to MP3 and measure the rendered file.

How ACX Ready fixes it

ACX Ready can't repair clipping. If the original recording was so loud it distorted, the distortion stays, and you need to re-record that part. Checking is free and you see the before and after numbers first. Downloading a whole book is £30 (about $41).

Check your peaks free

See the peak and RMS of any chapter before you change anything. Nothing is uploaded.

Check a chapter free

Fixing a whole book is £30 (about $41), with a full refund if ACX still rejects it. See what's included.

Questions

What peak level does ACX require?

Peaks must be no higher than -3 dB. Limiting to about -3.5 dB leaves a margin for MP3 encoding.

My WAV passed but the MP3 failed. Why?

MP3 encoding changes the waveform slightly and can raise peaks a little. Measure the exported MP3, and leave a small margin below -3 dB.

Is a peak above -3 dB the same as clipping?

No. Clipping happens at 0 dB, when the recording distorts. A peak between -3 dB and 0 dB is clean audio that is simply over ACX's limit, and a limiter fixes it.

Other ACX rejection reasons