ACX Ready / RMS too low

ACX says your RMS is too low. Here is the fix.

"Each file needs to fall between the specific volume range of -23dB and -18dB RMS for consistent volume."

ACX, ACX audio submission requirements

RMS is the average loudness of the whole file. ACX measures it across the entire chapter, pauses included. If the number comes out below -23 dB, the file is sent back as too quiet. Above -18 dB, it is too loud.

Why it happens

Most narrators set their microphone gain low so they never clip. That is good practice, but it leaves the recording around -26 to -30 dB RMS. Long pauses and quiet room tone pull the average down further.

The obvious fix, turning the whole file up, often fails a different rule. Your loudest words rise with everything else and cross the -3 dB peak limit. The background rises too, which can push the noise floor above -60 dB. Fixing RMS means raising the average while holding the peaks and the noise down.

How to fix it in Audacity

  1. Select the whole track with Ctrl+A.
  2. Open Effect > Volume and Compression > Loudness Normalization. Choose RMS and set it to -20 dB. That sits in the middle of ACX's range, so small changes later won't push you out.
  3. Open Effect > Volume and Compression > Limiter and limit to about -3.5 dB. This pulls back any peaks the normalisation pushed too high.
  4. Run Analyze > ACX Check. It reports peak level, RMS level and noise floor against ACX's limits.
  5. If the limiter cut a lot, RMS may drop a little. Run Loudness Normalization again at -20 dB, then the limiter, and check again.

How to fix it in Reaper

  1. Select the item and use Item > Item processing > Normalize items. Choose an RMS target and set it to -20 dB.
  2. Put a limiter on the track or master, such as ReaLimit or the JS Master Limiter, with the ceiling at -3.5 dB.
  3. In File > Render, you can also use Normalize/Limit to set the RMS target and a brickwall limit at render time.
  4. Measure the rendered MP3, not the project. MP3 encoding moves the numbers slightly.

How ACX Ready fixes it

Checking is free and you see the before and after numbers first. Downloading a whole book is £30 (about $41).

See your RMS in a minute

Drop in a chapter and get its RMS, peak and noise floor numbers. Nothing is uploaded.

Check a chapter free

Fixing a whole book is £30 (about $41), with a full refund if ACX still rejects it. See what's included.

Questions

What RMS level does ACX require?

Every file must measure between -23 dB and -18 dB RMS. Aim for about -20 dB so you have room either side.

Why did my RMS fail when it sounds loud enough?

RMS is an average over the whole file, including pauses. A recording with quiet gaps can sound fine and still average below -23 dB.

Can I just turn the file up?

Turning the whole file up raises peaks and background noise too. You usually need a limiter after the gain change so peaks stay under -3 dB, and noise reduction if the background rises above -60 dB.

Other ACX rejection reasons